Handling high-performing employees who lack self-awareness and are emotional can be a challenging task for any leader or manager. On one hand, you want to recognize and encourage their valuable contributions to the team or organization. On the other hand, you also need to address their behavior and help them become more self-aware and emotionally mature. In this blog, we will explore some effective ways to handle such situations with empathy and firmness.

  1. Start with empathy: Before jumping into any feedback or criticism, take a moment to understand the employee’s perspective. Try to put yourself in their shoes and imagine how they might be feeling. Acknowledge their emotions and validate their experience. This will help build trust and create a safe space for honest communication.
  2. Be specific and objective: When giving feedback, be specific about the behavior or situation that needs improvement. Avoid generalizing or personal attacks. Use concrete examples and facts to back up your observations. This will help the employee understand what they need to work on without feeling attacked or defensive.
  3. Use active listening: When the employee is responding to your feedback, use active listening techniques to show that you are fully present and interested in their perspective. Repeat what they have said to ensure that you have understood their point of view. This will help them feel heard and valued.
  4. Set clear expectations: Once you have discussed the behavior that needs improvement, set clear expectations for future performance. Explain what you expect from them and how you will measure their progress. This will help them focus on specific actions and goals rather than feeling overwhelmed or confused.
  5. Offer support: Offer your support and resources to help the employee improve their self-awareness and emotional maturity. Provide them with training, coaching, or mentoring opportunities. Encourage them to seek feedback from others and to reflect on their own behavior. This will show that you are invested in their growth and development.
  6. Follow up: Check in with the employee regularly to see how they are progressing. Offer feedback and encouragement along the way. Celebrate their successes and acknowledge their efforts. This will help build a positive and supportive relationship.

In conclusion, handling high-performing employees who lack self-awareness and are emotional requires a balance of empathy and firmness. By following the steps above, you can create a safe and supportive environment for honest communication and constructive feedback. Remember to be specific, objective, and clear in your expectations, while also offering support and encouragement. With time and effort, you can help your employee develop their emotional intelligence and become a more effective member of the team or organization.


About EvolveHR

Have any questions about this article or would like to explore how we can help your organization? Reach out to us and we’d be happy to assist.

Phone: 312-971-6332

Email: info@evolveHR.com


EvolveHR provides HR consulting services, payroll administration, employee benefits administration, HRIS services, HR risk management, HR organizational development to small, midsize and enterprise clients.